OpenCongress Blog
Blog Feed Comments Feed More RSS Feeds
Obama's Speech
September 9, 2009 - by Donny ShawIn case you missed it here’s the full video of President Obama’s address to a joint session of Congress on Wednesday night:
Here’s the healthcare plan he released just after the speech: The Obama Plan: Stability and Security for all Americans. And here’s some instant reaction, links and quote on the OpenCongres Twitter page.
Obama began the meat of the speech with a basic point that I think gets missed in a lot of the public debate over healthcare reform. “There is agreement in this chamber on about eighty percent of what needs to be done,” he said. He listed the major points of agreement: consumer protections including a ban on denying customers due to pre-existing conditions, a new health insurance exchange, and a requirement that all Americans get health insurance.
Then he went into the 20 percent area where there are disagreements. As expected, Obama said he supported a public insurance option, but he did not say that healthcare reform required it. He left open the ideas of triggers or co-ops, saying they were constructive ideas deserving of further discussion. “I will not back down on the basic principle that if Americans can’t find an affordable option, we will provide you with a choice,” Obama said to great applause. The line Obama’s drawing here seems to be that there must be a non-profit insurance company available should the private insurers fail to expand coverage on their own. The effectiveness of that option seems to be a secondary concern.
He also went over some common lies about the Democrats’ leading healthcare bill (H.R. 3200), and he actually called them “lies, plain and simple.” Pretty remarkable language for what we’ve seen so far in this debate. When he addressed the claim that the bill would provide healthcare subsidies for illegal immigrants, Rep. Joe Wilson [R, SC] shouted back, “you lie!” …He later apologized.
There was a lot more in the way of specifics in there, of course. Jonathan Cohn has a good rundown of the “news” in the speech, and you can find more along that line in the outline released by Obama tonight. Tons more analysis of the speech can be found via Memeorandum. All in all, I thought this was an impressive and moving speech that is only going to help Obama in achieving healthcare reform from Congress. What did you think? Anyone feeling or thinking differently after the speech?

Blog - Obama's Speech




Sort By
Comments
-President Barack Obama-Public Option + Cooperative = Bi-Partisanship
For us to break the stymie of health care reform we need to start looking at our options as being feasible contemporaneously. Would it not be our better interest to enact legislation so that both sides of the isle are represented ? It would allow both sides of the isle to be
an option. People will then make their own minds up as to which, if any, to select.
I look forward to a decent respect to the opinions of all my fellow man; Lest we expend Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness.
Sincere Regards
Roland D. Menard III
This doesn’t change anything for me. I have politely written to my congressman and the White House weeks ago and neither responded. One simple question: if I work for a large corporation with thousands of employees, whose bottom line is profit, why wouldn’t they switch to a cheap public option? Obama said there’s nothing in the bill to require me or my employer to change to the public option. That is not the same as his original promise that if I like my current insurance (which I love), I can keep it. He can’t guarantee that, so leading people to believe otherwise with clever word play is deception, is it not?
Does the tax credit work for people who have no income because they refuse to work, like my 29 year old brother? What about the guy who has been looking for work and has no income?
If they’re wrong and it does drive private insurer’s out of business, where do I get care if I don’t like their plan?
I’m listening…any answers?
Moderated Comment
He spoke for what 48 minutes? He said absolutely nothing new or enlightening about H.R. 3200. When he began to spell out how it will be paid for, he summed it up with the idea that about half would be paid for with savings from fixing inefficiencies in the system. Sigh. Nothing but rhetoric and trying to whip peoples emotions up. No substance whatsoever. Although his key purpose was stated “I will not back down”. Essentially I will cram this up your hole because I think its good for you. Rep Joe Wilson’s comment was inappropriate but highly accurate. Promises are being made that cannot be guaranteed. To have some one else provide healthcare for you is not a right. This little 48 minute waste of time was a pep talk and no more. Not an iota of substance in the whole speech, and a down right lie about not signing something that will add one dime to the deficit.
Not one word in the speech about the terrible care Americans take of themselves – the rampant obesity, the awful diet, the lack of exercise.
It was just one more example of promises to everyone that nobody will be hurt, nobody will pay. It’s not quite so blatant as what GWB did, but a step in the same direction.
The just way to handle health care insurance is to have every American on the same footing – able to apply for health insurance from a single provider with higher premiums for obesity, smoking, motorcycle riding, etc., all the things that are known hazards and result in extra costs for everyone – a simple system where one and all have the same standards applied and there is NO PROFIT in the insurance in itself.
It isn’t going to happen. We are going to trade one complicated byzantine system for another.
CB
I am confused by this from the speech: “Now, let me be clear. Let me be clear. It would only be an option for those who don’t have insurance. No one would be forced to choose it, and it would not impact those of you who already have insurance.”
Is he saying that if you have insurance, say through your employer, that you won’t be eligible for the govt plan? So…I can not elect to take the insurance my employer offers, then I am “eligible” for the govt plan? So essentially, everyone is eligible for the plan? If that’s what he’s saying then why confuse everyone with saying that “It would only be an option for those who don’t have insurance.”, why not say that everyone is eligible to elect the plan?
Why make health insurance mandatory? I don’t understand the logic here. He claims that we are forced to pick up the tab for people that don’t have health insurance….we are? I thought that one of the main reasons for healthcare reform was b/c people couldn’t afford healthcare insurance so if something did happen to them, then they are faced with huge medical bills. When have you heard of uninsured people having their medical bills paid for by the govt?? Also, likening health insurance to auto insurance just doesn’t make sense. First of all, only people that drive have auto insurance, secondly and most importantly, drivers have auto insurance b/c it insures the payment of damages to the OTHER people in the event of an accident if you are at fault. If I bite someone’s finger off, my health insurance isn’t going to pay for their hospital visit.
Why does he have to say we need to grow up and stop the name-calling, yet repeatedly he has been so butt hurt by people disagreeing with his “ideas” and flat out calls them “liars”! He is the one guilty of the accusations, we are only guilty of speaking our minds about what WE as a people know is best for us, which is a freedom given to us before BO was even thought of! If he thinks, that while on his power trip, he can TAKE AWAY OUR BASIC FREEDOMS, then we need to strip him of his power instantly and give it to someone fair, whether Dem or Rep, someone who will not threaten people to get them to listen, and will also listen to others! We don’t need the middle school games, we need a competent president!
I think Congressmen who oppose the socialist agenda of this president ought to speak out out turn at every opportunity they can, if they cannot, then we have totally lost our free speech. It seems likely Obama and the Left will pass a mediocre health care bill with so many loopholes, that essentialy it will tell the American people, “Here is your socialized medicine, like it or not” Here is the beginning folks towards a slippery slope into socialism and State control of our lives. Speak out against the socialism of this administration, become the bully and play their game. For Obama is the true Bully in this country.