OpenCongress Blog

Blog Feed Comments Feed More RSS Feeds

Republicans Agree to Drop 'Forcible Rape' Language From Abortion Bill

February 3, 2011 - by Donny Shaw

House Republicans are backing away from controversial language in their No Taxpayer Funding for Abortions Act that would change a long-standing exemption in abortion laws that allows federal funds to be used for abortions in the case of rape or incest by requiring that a rape be “forcible” to qualify. According to Politico, the bill’s author, Rep. Chris Smith [R, NJ-4], has agreed to amend the bill and remove the language after pro-choice groups and political commentators of all stripes expressed outrage.

“The word forcible will be replaced with the original language from the Hyde Amendment,” a spokesman for Rep. Smith told Politico.

The Hyde Amendment is a federal law banning the use of federal funds for elective abortions that is renewed annually as a rider on the Health and Human Services Appropriations bill. It applies primarily to Medicaid, but it will also be applied to all elements of the new health care reform law as it comes into effect over the next couple years. The No Taxpayers Funding for Abortions Act would make the Hyde Amendment permanent law so that it doesn’t have to be renewed every year.

More importantly, however, the bill would expand the Hyde Amendment to make it more difficult for businesses and individuals from using their own money to purchase health insurance that covers abortion services. The guiding theory behind the bill is that money is fungible, so no matter how carefully federal money is segregated from private money, the mere presence of federal money still frees up private money to be spent on abortions. It would, for example, block companies that offer their employees health plans that cover abortions from receiving tax credits. And individuals who buy their own policies would no longer be able to claim a deduction for the cost of their insurance policy if the policy covers abortions.

The dominant theory in the liberal blogosphere is that the rape-redefining language in the bill was never actually meant to become law. It was put in the bill to distract the pro-choice community from all the other stuff they wouldn’t like and would eventually be dropped to give the illusion of compromise, when in fact the Republicans are still getting everything they wanted. Sure enough, they’re dropping the rape language.

House Speaker John Boehner [R, OH] has said that this bill is one of his top priorities for the year. Expect action on it soon, and don’t be surprised if this, or some version of it, attracts a bit of Democratic support in the Senate as well.


Rep. Smith is pictured above.

Like this post? Stay in touch by following us on Twitter, joining us on Facebook, or by Subscribing with RSS.
John Boehner Chris Smith health care rape abortion
 

Comments

  • yoder 02/03/2011 9:06am
    Link Reply
    + 0
    ↓

    “…and don’t be surprised if this, or some version of it, attracts a bit of Democratic support in the Senate as well.”

    I won’t be surprised. So few on the (D) side have displayed anything resembling courage lately. I’m not saying that none on the (D) side have shown courage, just not nearly enough.

  • SmilingAhab 02/04/2011 5:46pm
    Link Reply
    + 0
    ↓

    The Democratic party is a weak, vapid, vacillating strawman for the Republicans and the Koch Brother’s PR campaign, the Tea Party™. I no longer recognize their legitimacy, and designate America as a one-party state – the Corporation. Obama built up our populist hopes so he and his corporate friends could have fun pissing all over our dreams of a more just union. I don’t recognize his legitimacy as President, nor do I very much recognize the legitimacy of America anymore.

    You wanna talk about marginalization of political opponents? Just take a look at how third parties are ridiculed in this country.

    At first all this was deep-state stuff to gain power. Now that Amerika Inc. has it, they’re just showing off. It makes me sick.

  • CANDY2011 02/11/2011 2:59pm
    Link Reply
    + 0
    ↓

    Manolo Blahnik Bottes http://www.louboutin-chaussure.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=11&zenid=hnfehk1s5f3r7hk4n8l5tbqlu2
    Manolo Blahnik Pompes http://www.louboutin-chaussure.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=12&zenid=hnfehk1s5f3r7hk4n8l5tbqlu2
    Manolo Blahnik Sandales http://www.louboutin-chaussure.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=13&zenid=hnfehk1s5f3r7hk4n8l5tbqlu2
    Yves Saint Laurent Bottes http://www.louboutin-chaussure.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=14&zenid=hnfehk1s5f3r7hk4n8l5tbqlu2
    Yves Saint Laurent Pompes http://www.louboutin-chaussure.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=15&zenid=hnfehk1s5f3r7hk4n8l5tbqlu2
    Yves Saint Laurent Sandales http://www.louboutin-chaussure.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=16&zenid=hnfehk1s5f3r7hk4n8l5tbqlu2

  • shunda2010 02/14/2011 2:40pm
    Link Reply
    + 0
    ↓

    AIR MAX 87 http://www.airmaxrequin.com/air-max-87-c-2.html
    AIR MAX 360 http://www.airmaxrequin.com/air-max-360-c-54.html
    AIR MAX 2010 http://www.airmaxrequin.com/air-max-2010-c-55.html
    AIR MAX 2009 http://www.airmaxrequin.com/air-max-2009-c-4.html
    AIR MAX 2003 http://www.airmaxrequin.com/air-max-2003-c-9.html
    AIR MAX 180 http://www.airmaxrequin.com/air-max-180-c-1.html
    AIR MAX LTD http://www.airmaxrequin.com/air-max-ltd-c-10.html

  • defu 03/06/2011 8:24pm
    Link Reply
    + 0
    ↓

    Autres http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/autres-c-39.html
    Botte http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/botte-c-34.html
    Chaussures de soiree http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/chaussures-de-soiree-c-40.html
    Chaussures Hommes Christian http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/chaussures-hommes-christian-c-38.html
    Christian Louboutin avec cale http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/christian-louboutin-avec-cale-c-32.html
    Christian Louboutin Plats http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/christian-louboutin-plats-c-33.html
    Escarpin http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/escarpin-c-31.html
    Jimmy Choo http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/jimmy-choo-c-37.html
    Manolo Blahnik http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/manolo-blahnik-c-35.html
    Sandale http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/sandale-c-30.html
    Sandales Louboutin Exclusives http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/sandales-louboutin-exclusives-c-29.html
    Yves Saint Laurent http://chaussures-louboutinfr.com/yves-saint-laurent-c-36.html

  • defu 03/08/2011 8:31pm
    Link Reply
    + 0
    ↓

    airmax-tn-requin http://airmax-tn-requin.com/
    Air Jordan Chaussure http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/air-jordan-chaussure-c-57.html
    Autres Chaussures Femme http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/autres-chaussures-femme-c-64.html
    Autres Chaussures Homme http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/autres-chaussures-homme-c-61.html
    Bonnets http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/bonnets-c-100.html
    Lunettes De Soleil http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/lunettes-de-soleil-c-89.html
    Nike Chaussure Femme http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/nike-chaussure-femme-c-43.html
    Nike Chaussure Homme http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/nike-chaussure-homme-c-1.html
    Sac Femme http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/sac-femme-c-77.html
    Timberland Chaussure http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/timberland-chaussure-c-68.html
    Vetements femme http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/vetements-femme-c-97.html
    Vetements Homme http://www.airmax-tn-requin.com/vetements-homme-c-73.html


Get Blog Updates by Email

Delivered by FeedBurner

Demand Question Time!



Find us at

Want a simple way to stay on top of what's happening in Congress?

Subscribe to this blog!

Send Us a Tip

You can submit a tip anonymously, or attributed to your own name and e-mail, whichever you prefer. Read more about submitting a tip.

Submit a tip




Recent Posts

Archives

See All Archives

Blogroll


See our Twitter List

Congress Watchers

OpenCongress is a free and open-source project of the Participatory Politics Foundation, a 501(c)3 non-profit organization with a mission to increase civic engagement. The non-profit Sunlight Foundation is the Founding and Primary Supporter of OpenCongress.