The Library of Congress  >  THOMAS Home  >  Committee Reports  >  Search Results

69-010

Calendar No. 839

110TH CONGRESS

Report

SENATE

2d Session

110-401

--NORTHWESTERN NEW MEXICO RURAL WATER PROJECTS ACT

June 25, 2008- Ordered to be printed

Mr. BINGAMAN, from the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, submitted the following

R E P O R T

[To accompany S. 1171]

SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.

Sec. 1. Short title.
Sec. 2. Definitions.
Sec. 3. Compliance with environmental laws.
Sec. 4. No reallocation of costs.
Sec. 5. Interest rate.
TITLE I--AMENDMENTS TO THE COLORADO RIVER STORAGE PROJECT ACT AND PUBLIC LAW 87-483
Sec. 101. Amendments to the Colorado River Storage Project Act.
Sec. 102. Amendments to Public Law 87-483.
Sec. 103. Effect on Federal water law.
TITLE II--RECLAMATION WATER SETTLEMENTS FUND
Sec. 201. Reclamation Water Settlements Fund.
TITLE III--NAVAJO-GALLUP WATER SUPPLY PROJECT
Sec. 301. Purposes.
Sec. 302. Authorization of Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project.
Sec. 303. Delivery and use of Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project water.
Sec. 304. Project contracts.
Sec. 305. Navajo Nation Municipal Pipeline.
Sec. 306. Authorization of conjunctive use wells.
Sec. 307. San Juan River Navajo Irrigation Projects.
Sec. 308. Other irrigation projects.
Sec. 309. Authorization of appropriations.
TITLE IV--NAVAJO NATION WATER RIGHTS
Sec. 401. Agreement.
Sec. 402. Trust Fund.
Sec. 403. Waivers and releases.
Sec. 404. Water rights held in trust.

SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.

SEC. 3. COMPLIANCE WITH ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS.

SEC. 4. NO REALLOCATION OF COSTS.

SEC. 5. INTEREST RATE.

TITLE I--AMENDMENTS TO THE COLORADO RIVER STORAGE PROJECT ACT AND PUBLIC LAW 87-483

SEC. 101. AMENDMENTS TO THE COLORADO RIVER STORAGE PROJECT ACT.

SEC. 102. AMENDMENTS TO PUBLIC LAW 87-483.

SEC. 103. EFFECT ON FEDERAL WATER LAW.

TITLE II--RECLAMATION WATER SETTLEMENTS FUND

SEC. 201. RECLAMATION WATER SETTLEMENTS FUND.

(aa) IN GENERAL- Except as provided under item (bb), the amount expended under subclause (I) shall not exceed $500,000,000 for the period of fiscal years 2009 through 2018.

(bb) EXCEPTION- The limitation on the expenditure amount under item (aa) may be exceeded during the entire period in which the Fund is in existence.

(aa) IN GENERAL- Except as provided under item (bb), the amount expended under subclause (I) shall not exceed $350,000,000 for the period of fiscal years 2009 through 2018.

(bb) EXCEPTION- The limitation on the expenditure amount under item (aa) may be exceeded during the entire period in which the Fund is in existence.

(cc) OTHER FUNDING- The Secretary shall ensure that any such funding shall be provided in a manner that does not limit the funding available pursuant to clauses (i) and (ii).

(aa) IN GENERAL- Except as provided under item (bb), the amount expended under subclause (I) shall not exceed $100,000,000 for the period of fiscal years 2009 through 2018.

(bb) EXCEPTION- The limitation on the expenditure amount under item (aa) may be exceeded during the entire period in which the Fund is in existence.

(cc) OTHER FUNDING- The Secretary shall ensure that any such funding shall be provided in a manner that does not limit the funding available pursuant to clauses (i) and (ii).

TITLE III--NAVAJO-GALLUP WATER SUPPLY PROJECT

SEC. 301. PURPOSES.

SEC. 302. AUTHORIZATION OF NAVAJO-GALLUP WATER SUPPLY PROJECT.

(aa) the Compact; and

(bb) other applicable law; and

(aa) the operation, maintenance, and replacement of each Project facility; and

(bb) the accounting and management of water conveyance and Project finances, as necessary to administer and fulfill the conditions of the Contract executed under section 304(a)(2)(B).

SEC. 303. DELIVERY AND USE OF NAVAJO-GALLUP WATER SUPPLY PROJECT WATER.

SEC. 304. PROJECT CONTRACTS.

SEC. 305. NAVAJO NATION MUNICIPAL PIPELINE.

SEC. 306. AUTHORIZATION OF CONJUNCTIVE USE WELLS.

SEC. 307. SAN JUAN RIVER NAVAJO IRRIGATION PROJECTS.

SEC. 308. OTHER IRRIGATION PROJECTS.

SEC. 309. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.

TITLE IV--NAVAJO NATION WATER RIGHTS

SEC. 401. AGREEMENT.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                   Diversion (acre-feet/year) Depletion (acre-feet/year) 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Navajo Indian Irrigation Project                      508,000                    270,000 
Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project                     22,650                     20,780 
Animas-La Plata Project                                 4,680                      2,340 
Total                                                 535,330                    293,120 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

SEC. 402. TRUST FUND.

SEC. 403. WAIVERS AND RELEASES.

SEC. 404. WATER RIGHTS HELD IN TRUST.

PURPOSE OF THE MEASURE

The purpose of S. 1171 is to amend the Colorado River Storage Project Act and Public Law 87-483 to authorize the construction and rehabilitation of water infrastructure in Northwestern New Mexico, to authorize the use of the reclamation fund to fund the Reclamation Water Settlements Fund, to authorize the conveyance of certain Reclamation land and infrastructure, to authorize the Commissioner of Reclamation to provide for the delivery of water, and for other purposes.

BACKGROUND AND NEED

In 1975, the State of New Mexico initiated a general stream adjudication to determine the quantity and priority of water rights in the San Juan River basin in New Mexico (State of New Mexico v. United States of America, Civ. No. 75-184 (11th Judicial Dist.)). The San Juan River is a tributary of the Colorado River and flows through the northwest portion of the state. The adjudication has been pending for over thirty years, and S. 1171 would implement a settlement to resolve the Navajo Nation's water rights, the largest claims in the adjudication.

The basis for the legislation is a settlement agreement executed by the Navajo Nation and the State of New Mexico on April 19, 2005, which requires Federal legislation to take effect. The agreement recognizes approximately 600,000 acre-feet per year (afy) of water rights available to the Navajo Nation for agricultural, municipal, industrial, domestic, and stock watering purposes, in return for a waiver of additional water rights and associated liability claims. A majority of the Navajo rights that would be adjudicated through the settlement have been recognized by prior federal laws, some of which are now proposed for amendment by S. 1171. The most significant of these is Public Law 87-483 (1962) which authorized construction of the Navajo Indian Irrigation Project (NIIP). The water supply for NIIP is provided by Navajo Reservoir, a Bureau of Reclamation project authorized by the 1956 Colorado River Storage Project Act. Public Law 87-483 also recognized the existence of several other Navajo irrigation projects, encompassing approximately 11,000 acres. Notwithstanding the 1962 law, NIIP has not been fully constructed. The settlement agreement and legislation amend Public Law 87-483 to allow the Navajo Nation to use the NIIP water supply for other purposes; establishes conditions that apply to any changes of use; and caps overall diversions of water for NIIP. There are also provisions specifically negotiated to protect existing water users in the basin.

S. 1171 also provides the means to address an ongoing need for drinking water on the Navajo Reservation through the construction of the Navajo-Gallup Pipeline Project (`Project'). Authorization and construction of the Project is critical to the Navajo Nation, and integral to the Nation's agreement to waive additional claims to water. According to an analysis performed by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, over 40% of Navajo households rely on water hauling to meet daily water needs. Also, 40% of Navajo families have incomes below the poverty level, compared with less than 10% nationwide. The lack of infrastructure, economic development, and sustained poverty are all closely connected. A reliable water supply is essential for stimulating and sustaining economic development in the region. The Project, by itself, will not eliminate water hauling on the Reservation, but it will reduce it by providing a reliable water supply of good quality much closer to many Navajo communities. The Project will also hook into existing distribution systems. Ultimately, the Project is expected to serve in excess of 203,000 tribal members in 43 different Navajo communities.

The Project will also serve other needs in New Mexico by providing a significant water supply to the city of Gallup, New Mexico, and, potentially, a smaller quantity to the Jicarilla Apache Tribe. Currently, Gallup relies on groundwater pumping to supply water to its residents. Due to falling water levels, the City anticipates significant shortages sometime between 2010 and 2016. The construction of the Project is critical to provide a long-term sustainable water supply to Gallup which expects to have a population of 47,000 people by 2040.

On March 30, 2007, the Bureau of Reclamation released a draft Environmental Impact Statement for the Navajo-Gallup Project which analyzes several alternatives for the Project. Another procedural hurdle was crossed in May 2006 when the Bureau of Reclamation issued a draft hydrologic determination finding that sufficient water exists from New Mexico's Upper Colorado River Basin allocation for Project needs through at least 2060. The Secretary of the Interior (Secretary) announced the approval of the hydrologic determination on June 8, 2007. Based on Reclamation's work, the Upper Colorado River Commission (representing Colorado, Wyoming, Utah, and New Mexico) approved a resolution in June 2006, supporting Congressional action to: (1) approve the Settlement Agreement; and (2) authorize the Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project.

LEGISLATIVE HISTORY

S. 1171 was introduced in the Senate on April 19, 2007 by Senator Bingaman for himself and Senator Domenici, and referred to the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources. The full committee held a hearing on S. 1171 on June 27, 2007. (S. Hrg. 110-148.) At its business meeting on May 7, 2008, the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources ordered S. 1171 favorably reported as amended.

COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION

The Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, in open business session on May 7, 2008, by voice vote of a quorum present, recommends that the Senate pass S. 1171, if amended as described herein.

COMMITTEE AMENDMENT

During the consideration of S. 1171, the Committee adopted a substitute amendment to improve the bill. The amendment incorporates a number of changes to several areas of the bill. The bill was amended to incorporate new definitions and to clarify that the new authorizations in S. 1171 would not result in a reallocation of costs under existing laws. There is also a new section that specifies the interest rate applicable to any new repayment contracts entered into by the Bureau of Reclamation.

Title I is amended in several places. These changes include modifications that clarify how the bill would change existing law, certain rights and responsibilities of the Navajo Nation with respect to existing facilities; and how shortages would be addressed for water made available from Navajo Reservoir.

Title II incorporates changes which have the effect of increasing the amount of funding available from the Reclamation Fund and the time frame for which such funding is available. The amendment also establishes a new set of priorities that will ensure that the Reclamation Fund can be used to implement certain settlements in New Mexico, Montana, and Arizona according to the time frame set out in Title II. The amendment also modifies how funds are invested before they are disbursed by the Secretary.

The amendments to Title III are numerous with a majority being technical in nature, such as referring to the Project as the Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project in all places in the bill. Other, more substantive changes include: (1) an increase in cost-share by the State of New Mexico; (2) clarifications to the authority of the Secretary to convey Project facilities to the Project participants; (3) modifications which specify the conditions under which the Project may deliver water to communities in Arizona; (4) the inclusion of more specific terms addressing project repayment and the responsibility for paying operation, maintenance, and replacement (OM&R) costs; and (5) new authorization of appropriations for the Secretary to pay a limited amount of OM&R for the Project.

Finally, the amendment includes a number of technical changes to Title IV of the bill. It also deletes a provision related to a hydrographic survey and expressly incorporates the waiver and release of certain legal claims upon implementation of the settlement.

SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS

Section 1 provides the short title of the Act and a table of contents.

Section 2 provides the definition of key terms used in the Act.

Section 3(a) states that the Secretary's execution of the Agreement shall not constitute a major federal action for purposes of the National Environmental Policy Act.

Section 3(b) expressly requires the Secretary to comply with all federal environmental laws in carrying out the provisions of the Act. Specific reference is made to the Endangered Species Act (ESA), and it is noted that the San Juan Recovery Implementation Program (SJRIP) is a key factor in ensuring that the Navajo-Gallup Project can result in new depletions from the San Juan River system while maintaining compliance with the ESA. It is expected that the SJRIP, including the development of a programmatic biological opinion by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, will help ensure that ESA compliance is maintained in the future notwithstanding the development of future water uses within the Colorado River apportionments made to the states of the Upper Colorado River Basin.

Section 4(a) ensures that the Act will not result in a reallocation or reassignment of existing costs under the Colorado River Storage Project Act.

Section 4(b) states that no power revenues under the Colorado River Storage Project Act will be used to pay for any costs associated with the Navajo Indian Irrigation Project or Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project.

Section 5 specifies the interest rate to be used for any repayment contract entered into under section 304 of the Act.

TITLE I--AMENDMENTS TO THE COLORADO RIVER

Section 101(a) amends the Colorado River Storage Project Act by adding the Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project as a participating project.

Section 101(b) amends the Colorado River Storage Project Act to authorize the Secretary to create a `top water bank' within the available capacity of Navajo Reservoir pursuant to specific criteria and conditions set forth in the provision.

Section 102(a) amends section 2 of Public Law 87-483 by striking the existing provision and replacing it with a new section 2 that maintains the long-standing authorization for the Navajo Indian Irrigation Project (NIIP) but includes several new provisions. The revised section 2 specifically sets forth the quantity of water available for the project; authorizes additional uses of that water; authorizes the transfer of that water outside NIIP and the Navajo reservation under certain conditions, authorizes the use of NIIP facilities to transport non-NIIP water if capacity is available; and directs that the use of NIIP water for non-irrigation purposes will not result in a reallocation of construction costs of NIIP. The new authority to use the capacity of NIIP to convey water for non-irrigation purposes does not authorize the Secretary to construct any new features to NIIP that were not already authorized under the Act of June 13, 1962. Also, subsection (f) under the revised section 2 continues the deferral of construction costs under the original Act, notwithstanding the possible use of NIIP facilities to deliver non-irrigation water.

Section 102(b) amends section 11 of P.L. 87-483 to add several new subsections. The first (subsection 11(d)) specifies how the Secretary is to determine and apportion shortages based on the prospective runoff originating above Navajo Reservoir and the available water in storage in Navajo Reservoir, including a provision that makes clear that the Secretary is to apply any shortage to the initial stage of the San Juan-Chama project against the full annual diversion demand of 135,000 acre-feet. The second new subsection (subsection 11(e)) specifies the order in which the Secretary will curtail releases and deliveries from Navajo Reservoir. The remaining new provisions (subsection 11(f)-(i)) declare that the Secretary shall apportion water on an annual volume basis; recognize that water may be distributed pursuant to cooperative agreements; and address diversions associated with a specific New Mexico State Engineer permit.

Section 103 disclaims any effect on certain specified Federal laws addressing water resources, unless expressly stated.

TITLE II--RECLAMATION WATER SETTLEMENTS FUND

Section 201(a) establishes the `Reclamation Water Settlements Fund' (Fund).

Section 201(b) directs that certain revenues be deposited in the Fund and provides that those funds be available without further appropriation pursuant to the section.

Section 201(c) specifies the conditions and criteria under which the Secretary of the Interior can expend money from the Reclamation Water Settlements Fund. First, the amounts available are specified. The purposes are also defined, which are to use the fund to implement a congressionally approved settlement agreement to the extent that the settlement requires the Bureau of Reclamation to provide financial assistance, or to plan, design, and construct certain types of projects. Only the settlement actions required to be carried out by the Bureau of Reclamation and which fit the specified criteria, are to be funded using the Fund. This subsection also specifies the priorities for spending from the Fund and directs the Secretary to reserve the specified quantities to ensure that a minimum of such funding is available in the event that appropriations are not sufficient to implement certain activities by the deadlines set forth in the settlement legislation. The first priority is funding to construct the Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project. The second priority is the funding needed to help implement two other identified settlements in New Mexico. The third priority is the expenditure of funds to help implement three identified settlements in Montana. The fourth priority is the specified funding needed to help implement an identified settlement in Arizona. While other settlements may qualify for expenditures from the fund, the identified settlements will be the priorities subject to the requirement that Federal legislation is enacted to authorize such settlements by December 31, 2014.

Section 201(d) directs the Secretary to invest the amounts in the Fund and retains the benefits of that investment in the Fund.

Section 201(e) addresses timing and adjustments issues associated with transferring amounts to the Fund.

Section 201(f) specifies that the Fund will terminate on September 30, 2028, and any balance will be returned to the appropriate fund in the Treasury, which includes the Reclamation Fund.

TITLE III--NAVAJO-GALLUP WATER SUPPLY PROJECT

Section 301 describes the purposes of Title III.

Section 302(a) authorizes the Secretary, acting through the Commissioner of Reclamation to carry-out a range of activities to construct and operate the Navajo-Gallup Water Supply Project. Completion of the Project is one of the conditions required to implement the settlement of the Navajo Nation's water rights claims in the San Juan River basin.

Section 302(b) authorizes the Secretary to construct, operate, and maintain a number of identified facilities associated with the Project.

Section 302(c) authorizes the Secretary to acquire the property interests necessary to construct, operate, and maintain the Project, subject to the requirement that the Project Participants provide any ownership interest they have in such properties at no cost to the Secretary.

Section 302(d) specifies a number of conditions that must be met before the Secretary is to commence construction of the Project. One of the conditions is the completion of an agreement with the State of New Mexico concerning its cost-share associated with the Project. The Secretary will use any such funds provided by New Mexico pursua