OpenCongress Blog

Blog Feed Comments Feed More RSS Feeds

Boehner: White House Plan is Too Short

February 23, 2010 - by Donny Shaw

House Minority Leader Rep. John Boehner [R, OH-8] is attacking the President’s new health care plan by calling it too short. Talking Points Memo reports:

A spokesman for House Minority Leader John Boehner today ridiculed President Obama’s health care proposal because it’s too short.

"The White House’s ‘plan’ consists of an 11-page outline, which has not been scored by the Congressional Budget Office or posted online as legislative text. So they want to reorganize one-sixth of the United States’ economy with a document shorter than a comic book, and they’re complaining that they can’t find our plan on their own website? C’mon," said the spokesman, Michael Steel, in an email to reporters.

So, obviously, this is ironic because for months the Republicans have been complaining that Congress’ health care plans are too long. But what is really ridiculous here is that the White House plan that was released yesterday is not a bill, and it only deals with a small portion of the health care bills in Congress. If it was written as a bill instead of the more friendly, plain English outline it is, it would probably be somewhere between the lengths of the Senate and House health care bills. And those, of course, are “too long.”

Plus, the White House’s choice to release an outline rather than a new bill makes it much easier to incorporate any new Republican ideas that come out of the summit this week.

What this really illustrates is that, even though the health care bills in Congress are long documents, if you distill them down into plain English and describe each provision, they end up being a very reasonable length. We saw this with the Senate bill also, which was written in pal English before it was marked up into legalese. The plain English version was 223 pages long, but when it was translated into an actual legislative language it turned into more than 2,000 pages. Nothing new was added, it’s just the fact that bills are written differently than texts that are designed to be read by people.

Like this post? Stay in touch by following us on Twitter, joining us on Facebook, or by Subscribing with RSS.


  • Sgant2nd 02/23/2010 7:34am

    Too long… too short… make up your minds Repubs’!!!!!!

  • sbrawsm 02/23/2010 8:31am

    The point was, the White House did not introduce a bill, it was an outline of a bill. You are getting sucked into the liberal bias presented in this article.
    If it is not a bill, do not call it a bill. Call it what it was – an outline.

  • becauseican 11/09/2011 1:09am

    Thank you for the posts. I found the information to be informative and useful.
    roof repairs walnut creek

  • Spam Comment

  • Spam Comment

Due to the archiving of this blog, comment posting has been disabled.